Concierge Home Care vs. Private Duty Care: What’s the Difference?

The short answer: Private duty describes how care is arranged and paid for: one-to-one help paid privately, often by the hour or shift. Concierge describes how care is delivered. One service can be both; the practical decision is who will arrange and manage the care.
Concierge home care describes non-medical support organized around an RN-directed plan, one shared record, and provider coordination; our guide to what concierge home care means explains those practices.
| The term | What it means | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Private duty | Privately paid, one-to-one care at home | A clear rate, schedule, and list of included tasks |
| Concierge home care | Non-medical help built around an RN-directed plan, one shared record, and provider coordination. | Ask to see how the RN-directed plan, current record, and provider coordination work together |
| Private duty nursing | Clinical services provided by a licensed nurse and arranged separately from non-medical caregiving | Identify which clinical tasks require an RN or LVN |
Who should arrange the care: an agency, a direct hire, or a registry?
A friend recommends a caregiver who charges $25 an hour, less than the agency rates you have seen. Before you decide, consider what comes with that lower wage—and what work you would take on yourself. The example below puts some of those costs on paper.
| What matters | Licensed agency | Direct hire | Referral registry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Employment | The agency employs its affiliated aide | The family may be the household employer, depending on the working relationship | A registry may only refer; clarify who employs and controls the work |
| Screening | California requires agency-affiliated aides to be registered; the agency handles its hiring and screening process | The family checks identity, references, qualifications, and applicable background information | Ask what the registry checks and what remains for the family |
| When a caregiver is absent | Scheduling is coordinated by the agency; coverage depends on the arrangement | The family arranges a substitute or covers the visit | Backup is not automatic; confirm whether replacement help is offered |
| Payroll and taxes | The agency handles employee payroll | Household payroll and tax duties may apply | Duties depend on who employs the caregiver |
| Insurance | A licensed California Home Care Organization must maintain required coverage and bond | The family must understand applicable workers’ compensation and liability coverage | Ask what coverage belongs to the registry versus the caregiver or family |
What this means for you: Direct hire can offer more control and a lower quoted hourly wage, but the family may take on screening, payroll, schedule changes, and insurance questions. A registry may introduce a caregiver without managing the employment relationship. A licensed agency fits when you want an organization to employ caregivers and handle hiring and payroll. Compare the actual agreement, services, and coverage.
California rules that affect direct hire
As of November 4, 2026. This is educational information, not legal or tax advice; a payroll professional can assess how the rules apply to a specific arrangement.
A worker’s status depends on the facts, including who controls the work. Under California’s Domestic Worker Bill of Rights, covered personal attendants generally receive overtime after nine hours in a day or 45 hours in a week. Other domestic workers may have different California thresholds. Federal law generally requires covered, nonexempt domestic service employees to receive overtime after 40 hours in a workweek. Which rules apply depends on the worker and employment arrangement.
California requires aides employed by a licensed Home Care Organization to be listed on the Home Care Aide Registry; listing rules differ for aides employed outside an HCO.
The real cost of hiring directly: a worked example
Assume a family hires a non-live-in caregiver at $25 an hour for four 10-hour days each week, and that the worker qualifies as a personal attendant. Under the California rule, this schedule includes one daily overtime hour on each 10-hour day: 36 regular hours and four overtime hours.
| Weekly item | Illustrative amount |
|---|---|
| 36 regular hours × $25 | $900.00 |
| 4 daily overtime hours × $37.50 (1.5 × $25) | $150.00 |
| Wages before employer taxes | $1,050.00 |
| Employer Social Security and Medicare (7.65% of wages) | $80.33 |
| Assumed insurance/payroll-administration allowance | $30.00 |
| Assumed backup-care reserve | $100.00 |
| Illustrative weekly total | $1,260.33 |
The total, $1,260.33 for 40 hours, equals about $31.51 per hour. CareScout’s 2025 survey reports a $40 California median hourly rate for non-medical caregivers; at that benchmark, 40 hours would be $1,600 per week. The difference is $339.67 per week, or about $8.49 per hour. In this example, direct hire remains less expensive than the statewide agency median, although the gap is smaller than the $15 difference between the assumed wage and benchmark.
An agency arrangement puts screened hiring, employee payroll, and organizational insurance with the provider. That means someone else handles household payroll taxes and workers’ compensation, rather than leaving you to manage them as the caregiver’s employer. With Home Care also brings RN direction to the non-medical plan. Whether the difference is worthwhile depends on how much of that work your family wants to take on.
Example assumptions: The $25 wage, $30 weekly insurance/payroll allowance, and $100 backup reserve are planning assumptions; actual costs vary, and unemployment taxes, paid leave, and other employer costs are excluded. This 40-hour personal-attendant example includes California daily overtime but does not exceed the federal weekly threshold; employment and tax rules depend on the arrangement. The $40 survey benchmark is not a With Home Care quote, and services included in actual rates vary.
Private duty nursing and non-medical caregiving do different work
A non-medical caregiver helps with daily routines such as dressing, meals, companionship, errands, and light housekeeping. An RN or, in California, an LVN provides clinical nursing within the nurse’s license and care arrangement. For example, a parent receiving tube feeding may need a nurse to manage the clinical feeding task while a caregiver helps with bathing, company, and the rest of the day.
CareScout also reports $110 per hour for private-duty nurses and $208 per nursing visit. A visit rate reflects a shorter task-based visit, not a full hourly shift. See the CareScout 2025 Cost of Care Survey.
With Home Care does not provide clinical nursing. Our RN directs non-medical care planning; our caregivers provide non-medical assistance. When your parent receives nursing or home-health services, our caregivers work alongside that clinical team within their role. Our FAQ explains the medical-care boundary.
Which arrangement fits your family?
- You want to hire and direct the caregiver yourself: Direct hire gives you more control, along with responsibility for employment, payroll, screening, schedule changes, and coverage arrangements.
- You want help finding a caregiver but plan to manage the relationship: A registry may introduce you to candidates. Confirm whether it employs anyone, screens candidates, or provides replacement care.
- You want an organization to handle hiring and coordination: A licensed agency fits when you do not want to manage employment details and payroll yourself. Review its written scope and included services.
- Your parent needs a clinical task plus daily help: Arrange the clinical task with a licensed nurse or appropriate home-health provider, and use non-medical caregiving for everyday routines.
How With Home Care handles the agency arrangement
- Employment: We employ our caregivers directly. With Home Care is a licensed California Home Care Organization (HCO #304700412).
- Screening: Our caregivers complete background checks and health screenings.
- Payroll: We handle payroll and employer taxes.
- Insurance: We’re insured and carry the coverage California requires of licensed home care organizations.
- Care planning: Our RN directs non-medical care plans, and every caregiver works from one current record.
A decision that includes the work behind the hourly rate
The hourly wage tells only part of the story. Once you have a complete budget and know who will handle hiring, payroll, coverage, and care planning, you can choose an arrangement that fits both your finances and the responsibilities you want to take on.
For a complimentary care assessment, call (714) 732-6176 or contact With Home Care. Tell us what kind of help your parent needs and ask about the services and arrangements available to your family.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to hire a caregiver directly?
It can be, but by less than the hourly wage suggests. In this illustration, a $25-an-hour wage becomes about $31.51 an hour after daily overtime, employer taxes, and the stated insurance/payroll and backup allowances, compared with the $40 California agency median. The remaining difference pays for agency screening, payroll administration, and organizational insurance, with the agency employing the caregiver instead of your family. Whether that is worth it depends on how much of that work you want to take on; the figures are illustrative, not a With Home Care quote.
Can long-term care insurance reimburse private-duty care?
Some policies cover care from licensed agencies, while provider and service rules vary. Check your policy’s definition of covered care, waiting period, documentation requirements, and whether it accepts a directly hired caregiver before signing an agreement.
Is private duty the same as Medicare home health?
No. Medicare may cover eligible intermittent skilled home-health services under its rules; it does not cover ongoing non-medical custodial care as a standalone service. See Medicare’s home-health coverage for current eligibility details.